Skip to content

Rangers Face 40-Man Deadline With Three Rule 5-Eligible Prospects

Texas Rangers outfield prospect Hector Osorio stands in the batter's box during a minor league game

The Texas Rangers have until 5 p.m. Tuesday to set their 40-man roster and protect eligible prospects from the Rule 5 draft, though it remains unclear whether the draft will be held at all.

The draft is currently scheduled for Dec. 9, but a work stoppage expected to begin the prior week could prevent it. The league did not hold a Rule 5 draft after the lockout five years ago, and a similar situation could occur this time around.

Under the rules, players signed as 18-year-olds or younger who have spent five seasons in an organization, and players signed at 19 or older who have spent four seasons in an organization, must be added to the 40-man roster to be protected. A player left unprotected and selected must spend the following season on his new club’s 26-man active roster and can only be removed if he passes through waivers.

The Rangers have experience on both sides of that equation. They acquired right-handed pitcher Carter Baumler during last year’s Rule 5 draft and carried him, both on the active roster and the injured list, for the duration of this season. They have also lost players, most notably right-handed pitcher Justin Slaten, whom they left unprotected three years ago. Slaten has since compiled 2.4 WAR over three seasons in the Boston Red Sox bullpen, per FanGraphs — more than all but two of the Rangers’ homegrown pitchers have totaled for them since.

Three of the Rangers’ Rule 5-eligible players rank among their top 30 prospects, according to Baseball America. Roster space is tight: the club has only three open 40-man spots and has not yet signed a free agent, meaning moves will almost certainly be required to fit everyone in.

OF Hector Osorio

Osorio is the club’s No. 16 prospect per Baseball America and the highest-ranked player currently unprotected. The 21-year-old had a breakout season with a .295/.411/.543 slash line, 21 home runs and more walks than strikeouts at both Single-A levels, credited to a physical transformation.

He is not considered major league ready — MLB Pipeline lists a 2028 ETA — and has not taken an at-bat above High-A, nor spent more than two seasons above rookie ball. The question is whether that recent body of work is enough for another team to carry him for a full season, or whether the Rangers can slip him through. Committing a 40-man spot to a player who still needs to prove himself against more advanced minor league arms is difficult to justify, but so is losing a young hitter who appears to be on the rise.

RHP Wilian Bormie

Bormie, the No. 25 prospect per Baseball America, profiles as a bullpen flier. The 25-year-old posted a 2.61 ERA and 72 strikeouts in 58 2/3 innings split between Double-A Frisco and Triple-A Round Rock this season.

His four-seam fastball averaged 98 mph, cleared triple digits, and paired well with a mid-80s slider — a prototypical single-inning arsenal. Because it played against Double-A and Triple-A hitters, an argument can be made it should be tested against big leaguers next. The Rangers need to bolster their bullpen, and Bormie, whether protected or undrafted, could have to compete for a roster spot in spring training. Other clubs in need of a hard thrower in relief could complicate matters.

RHP Izack Tiger

Tiger’s situation is not entirely dissimilar from Baumler’s: an older, injured arm with upside. The 25-year-old has one of the system’s better fastballs, a four-seamer that has reached triple digits, but he has appeared in only 25 games over the last three seasons because of elbow surgery.

He logged 27 1/3 innings this season, struck out 14.16 batters per nine, and performed well against Arizona Complex League competition before a bumpy finish at High-A Hub City. There is a reason Tiger is only the club’s No. 26 prospect per Baseball America despite high-caliber stuff: his health, age and professional inexperience create a risk factor. He will be 26 to start next season without experience above High-A, a lot for any team to bank on even if the talent is impressive.

Other eligible names to know

Right-handed pitcher Ismael Agreda is one of the better unranked prospects available, but after a 5.88 ERA in 98 innings largely spent at High-A last season, it is hard to envision him as a serious Rule 5 candidate. Outfielder Aaron Zavala, a 26-year-old former second-round pick, has posted consecutive seasons with a .769 OPS or better, raising the question of whether he moves the needle for a team seeking depth at the position.

Right-handed pitcher Ryan Lobus and left-handed pitcher Josh Trentadue both spent parts of last camp with the big league team. Lobus impressed as a relief pitcher in spring training and reached Triple-A this season, while Trentadue was once a top-30 prospect in the organization. Others eligible, such as right-handed pitcher Enrique Segura, have some support in prospect circles but not enough track record or immediate talent to warrant protection.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *